The Cracks in MAGA
Who’s Leaving, Who’s Shifting, and Why
The “Make America Great Again” movement exploded onto the political scene in 2016 with firebrand energy and a promise to overthrow the globalist order, drain the D.C. swamp, and return the American republic to its people. Eight years later, it still commands a cult-like following — but behind the chants and red hats, the MAGA coalition is fracturing.
In 2025, after a volatile U.S. election, Trump’s legal troubles, the Israel–Iran war, and renewed scrutiny over Jeffrey Epstein's elite blackmail network, some of MAGA’s most recognizable voices are breaking away — not from populism, but from the illusion that Trump’s MAGA was ever truly anti-establishment.
The 2025 Catalyst: Israel–Iran War & Elite Protection
The Turning Point: The 2025 Middle East Explosion:
The April–June 2025 conflict between Israel and Iran shocked even hardened MAGA supporters. While the movement has historically been unconditionally pro-Israel, this war — with Israeli bombings in Isfahan, Tabriz, and Basra, and Iranian retaliatory strikes on Tel Aviv and Haifa — forced a reassessment.
What happened:
Over 15,000 civilians reportedly killed in Gaza and Southern Lebanon since October 2024.
Iran directly attacked Israel in April 2025 — the first time in modern history.
The U.S. military backed Israel through air defense and logistics, despite Trump-era isolationist rhetoric.
This rupture has re-opened a long-suppressed question inside MAGA: Is the U.S. truly sovereign if it acts as a proxy for foreign nations — even allies?
The Epstein-Wexner Abyss: The Swamp MAGA Never Drained
As fresh documents from Ghislaine Maxwell’s sealed testimony and Leslie Wexner’s connections to Mossad emerged in early 2025, MAGA’s base started to question why Trump never pursued justice for Epstein's crimes.
Despite promising to expose the elite class, Trump:
Never ordered a full DOJ investigation into Epstein’s intelligence ties.
Associated socially with Epstein and Wexner-linked elites during his pre-presidency years.
Appointed Bill Barr as Attorney General — whose father hired Epstein at the Dalton School.
This betrayal is especially potent among younger right-wing audiences, who increasingly view the Epstein affair not as a scandal, but as a keystone conspiracy linking intelligence agencies, global finance, child trafficking, and compromised politicians — across both parties.
The Departure Lounge: Who’s Leaving MAGA and Why
Elon Musk: The Parallel Power Broker
Then: Anti-woke free speech crusader, MAGA-adjacent via Twitter/X.
Now: Explicitly distancing from Trump; backed Ron DeSantis, praised RFK Jr.
Why: Seeks a rational, technocratic populism — not Trumpian chaos.
Tucker Carlson: MAGA’s Orphan Prophet
Then: Fox News firebrand aligned with Trump’s base.
Now: Independent thinker; interviews with Putin, Orban, anti-war voices.
Why: Believes both parties protect elite crimes and foreign lobbies.
Candace Owens: From Darling to Dissident
Then: Daily Wire star and one of MAGA’s most loyal defenders.
Now: Critic of Israeli war crimes, canceled by Shapiro and MAGA donors.
Why: Wants Christian nationalism, not Zionist neo-imperialism.
Vivek Ramaswamy: MAGA 2.0 or Controlled Populist?
Then: Self-proclaimed heir to Trumpism.
Now: More policy-focused; critical of Trump’s legacy.
Why: Alienated by Trump’s refusal to challenge Big Pharma, Big Tech, and the MIC.
Ann Coulter: The Unforgiving Oracle
Then: Trump’s early champion.
Now: His harshest critic.
Why: "He promised to build a wall and jail Hillary. He built nothing and hired her friends."
Joe Rogan: Voice of the Disenchanted Center
Then: Gateway to MAGA-aligned voices.
Now: Platforming RFK Jr., anti-war vets, and system reformers.
Why: Tired of culture war without results. Sees Trump vs. Biden as a rigged replay.
The Ideological Shift: Populism Without Trump?
What we’re seeing now is not the end of populism — but the end of Trump’s monopoly over it.
Many of those abandoning MAGA aren’t returning to liberalism. They’re moving toward:
Nationalism without foreign entanglements
Populism without celebrity theatrics
Anti-elitism that actually targets elite immunity
Technocratic reform without geriatric demagogues
Conclusion: MAGA Is Splintering — and That’s a Good Thing
MAGA once unified the disillusioned. Now it confuses them.
What began as a rebellion against the globalist elite is now torn between celebrity loyalty, foreign policy contradictions, and unfulfilled promises.
If 2016 was the birth of a populist revolt, then 2025 is its moment of reckoning.
Whether it breaks apart, evolves, or is replaced by something sharper remains unknown — but one thing is certain:
The next true populist movement will have to go deeper than slogans — and be brave enough to name the real elites.